Judge reduces punitive damages against Hyundai in fatal Montana traffic crash
Judge reduces punitive damages against Hyundai in fatal Montana traffic crash
  • by Korea IT Times(info@koreaittimes.com)
  • 승인 2014.09.30 18:54
  • 댓글 0
이 기사를 공유합니다

SEOUL, KOREA -In May of this year, a jury in Montana ruled against Hyundai, siding with the families of two teenage boys who died in a 2005 Hyundai Tiburon. The jury set a massive, $240 million penalty, which Hyundai subsequently appealed.

The crashed Tiburon(sold in name of Tuscani in Korea) of Hyundai on NBC Montana

According to the Associated press, the judge in the case has now cut that fine by about two-thirds, to $73 million. Will Hyundai appeal again

The families of cousins Trevor and Tanner Olson claimed that the Tiburon Trevor drove had a defective steering knuckle. That defect, they alleged, led to the fatal collision that killed not only the Olsons, but also Stephanie Nicole Parker-Shepherd, a passenger in a vehicle that the Tiburon hit.

However, there are some complicating facts in the case:

Despite those doubts, the jury found in favor of the plaintiffs. It set a fine of $240 million -- the largest penalty ever issued against Hyundai and three times larger than the plaintiffs had sought. That figure is over and above the $8.1 million in real damages awarded to the Olsons' families.

Hyundai appealed the ruling, and Judge Deborah Kim Christopher has scaled back the punitive damages to $73 million, which is more in line with what the Olsons had originally wanted. Paired with the existing $8.1 million in actual damages, that put Hyundai's payout at just over $81 million.

Hyundai still wasn't satisfied, though, pointing to the fact that Montana caps punitive damages at $10 million. In response, Judge Christopher said that the state's monetary cap was unconstitutional. Furthermore, she alleged that Hyundai has exhibited a decade-long pattern of negligence with its vehicles, which justified the higher fine.

Hyundai plans to appeal once again, insisting that Montana's cap on punitive damages is, in fact, quite legal. Hyundai's Jim Trainor issued this statement:

"Hyundai believes the rulings are erroneous and constitute an extreme outlier in the law on punitive damages. Virtually every other state court that has considered the constitutionality of punitive damages caps has held that such laws do not violate the jury trial right because the jury’s fact-finding function is preserved. Nationally, both state and federal courts consistently have upheld the constitutionality of punitive damages caps. With these rulings and the other erroneous rulings made at trial, Hyundai looks forward to its appeal in this matter."

by Lee Jae-sueng (jasonlee@koreaittimes.com)

삭제한 댓글은 다시 복구할 수 없습니다.
그래도 삭제하시겠습니까?
댓글 0
계정을 선택하시면 로그인·계정인증을 통해
댓글을 남기실 수 있습니다.

  • #1206, 36-4 Yeouido-dong, Yeongdeungpo-gu, Seoul, Korea(Postal Code 07331)
  • 서울특별시 영등포구 여의도동 36-4 (국제금융로8길 34) / 오륜빌딩 1206호
  • URL: www.koreaittimes.com / m.koreaittimes.com. Editorial Div. 02-578-0434 / 010-2442-9446. Email: info@koreaittimes.com.
  • Publisher: Monica Younsoo Chung. CEO: Lee Kap-soo. Editor: Jung Yeon-jin. Juvenile Protection Manager: Yeon Choul-woong.
  • IT Times Canada: Willow St. Vancouver BC, Canada / 070-7008-0005.
  • Copyright(C) Korea IT Times, Allrights reserved.